The Foundation for Constitutional Democracy

  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • Beliefs & Perspectives
  • Judaism
  • 10 Short Position Papers – IV
Judaism Papers Party Structures

10 Short Position Papers – IV

by LanoitYarcoOctober 5, 1999August 10, 20200484
Share0

IV – How To Gain Support From Religious Parties
Professor Paul Eidelberg July 5, 1999.

The religious parties are inclined to oppose a constitution. They fear it will legitimize and further enlarge the power of the Supreme Court, which not only has a Meretz-Shinui agenda, but has usurped powers rightly belonging to the legislative and executive branches of government. (This is why the religious parties—and not only the religious parties—would oppose the Reichman constitution, which would lead to “government by the judiciary.”)

Although our Foundation, which advocates a constitution, includes rabbis—indeed, no less than the renowned Rav Aaron Soloveitchik has consented to serve as our Halachic adviser—still, many religious people object to a constitution saying, “We have a constitution, the Torah.” There are ways of overcoming such opposition.

First, the Foundation has shown that the flaws in Israel existing political system are undermining the State, hence harming religious and non-religious Jews alike. Second, it should be noted that the religious parties supported a constitution proposed in 1949. (For details, see my paper “A Constitution for Israel.”)

Third, it may be asked, with all due respect for Israel’s learned rabbis: “Would investing them with the legislative as well as judicial powers of the Sanhedrin be acceptable to the majority of Israel’s Jewish population—as it must be according to Jewish law? Moreover, on what prominent Jew would the people of Israel be willing to bestow the executive power and life tenure of a king? And where are the prophets who, like those of old, admonished kings who strayed from the Torah?

The fears of the religious aside, we recommend that the powers of the Supreme Court be carefully delineated in any constitution. A constitution may specify that the Court may exercise only procedural, and not substantive, judicial review. Alternatively, the constitution may stipulate, as does Ireland’s, that the President—in a presidential system—may, after consultation with his cabinet, refer any Bill (other than appropriations bills) to the Supreme Court for decision on the question as to whether such a Bill is repugnant to the Constitution.

Most important, however, is this. Any proposed constitution should state that, among the diverse systems of law operative in Israel, Jewish law shall be “first among equals” in every case where an Israeli statute is ambiguous or uncertain, except only where the Israeli statute explicitly differs from Jewish law. This conforms to the Foundations of Law Act passed by the Knesset in 1980, but very much ignored by the Supreme Court which still relies on English law, and more recently on American law.

Consistent with that Act, the constitution should specify that at least two-thirds of the Supreme Court’s membership should be learned in Jewish as well as secular law. This will allay the fears of religious Jews. And as Professor Menachem Alon, former Vice-President of the Supreme Court, has shown, further incorporation of Jewish civil law into Israel’s legal system would foster unity among Jews of diverse ethnic backgrounds.

Share0
previous post
10 Short Position Papers – VII
next post
On Rabbis and Self-Restraint
LanoitYarco

Related Articles

The Jerusalem Temple Mount

LanoitYarcoAugust 7, 2007August 9, 2020

Israel’s Existential Dilemma

LanoitYarcoNovember 30, 2009August 7, 2020

Kings, Presidents, and Israel’s Prime Minister

LanoitYarcoJanuary 1, 2002August 10, 2020

Israel and USA News

The Foundation Blog strives to provide Israel and USA News, and offers a wide range of statistics and analyzed opinions of many correspondents who highlight developments and events from Jewish people and communities in Israel and the USA as well. If you would like to know more about reliable political news and if you need more information about today in Israel news, do not hesitate to contact foundation1.org

Recent Posts

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200

Categories

  • Islam & Arab (79)
  • Democratic Methods (76)
  • Judaism (72)
  • Politicians (64)
  • Beliefs & Perspectives (64)
  • Oslo/Peace Process (63)
  • Ethics (59)
  • US & Global Policy (49)
  • Currnet Issues (48)
  • Foreign Policy (35)
  • Representation (28)
  • Israel’s Sovereignty (27)

Today in Israel News

The Research Institute Oslo Peace plans research on the circumstances and all conditions in order to manage peaceful relations between states, people and groups. This is an independent institute that owns its personal editorial offices and journals. By following the Foundation Blog, you will be updated about Israel and USA news and also the latest democratic political news.

Editor's Picks

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200
logo
Get in Touch
Contact us: [email protected]
@2019 - foundation1.org. All Right Reserved.
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
1079