The Foundation for Constitutional Democracy

  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • Government Branches
  • Supreme Court/Judicial
  • The Need to Restrain Israel’s Supreme Court
Supreme Court/Judicial

The Need to Restrain Israel’s Supreme Court

by LanoitYarcoNovember 4, 2007August 12, 20200292
Share0

Eminent persons across political spectrum in Israel—judges, academics, and lawyers—have said that Israel’s Supreme Court, especially under its former President Aharon Barak, has exceeded its prescribed powers and has handed down many decisions that violate basic principles of democracy, to say nothing of Zionism and Judaism.

Since the Knesset’s Constitution, Law and Justice Committee is presently engaged in drafting a constitution for the State of Israel, it behooves the members of this Committee to curb the judicial imperialism of the Supreme Court. The mode of appointing the judges of the Court should be crafted in such a way as to deter the Court from arrogating to itself powers or functions which, as a matter of principle and of prudence, rightfully belong to the Legislative and Executive branches of government.

To this end the Committee should study judicial self-restraint of Justice Louis Brandeis who, in 1936, codified a series of rules which the United States Supreme Court had developed for its own governance, under which is has avoided passing upon a large part of all the constitutional questions pressed upon it for decision. They were seven in number:

  1. The Court will not pass upon the constitutionality of legislation in a friendly, non-adversary, proceeding, declining because to decide such questions is legitimate only in the last resort, ands as a necessity in the determination of real, earnest and vital controversy between individuals;
  2. The Court will not anticipate a question of constitutional law in advance of the necessity of deciding it;
  3. The Court will not formulate a rule of constitutional law broader than is require by the precise facts to which it is to be applied;
  4. The Court will not pass upon a constitutional question although properly presented by the record, if there is also present some other ground upon which the case may be disposed of;
  5. The Court will not pass on the validity of a statute upon the complaint of one who fails to show that he is injured by its operation;
  6. The Court will not pass upon the constitutionality of a statute at the instance of one who has availed himself of its benefits; and
  7. When the validity of an act of Congress is drawn in question, and even if a serious doubt of constitutionality is raise, it is a cardinal principle that this Court will first ascertain whether a construction of the statute is fairly possible by which the question may be avoided.

It may be worthwhile for the Constitution, Law and Justice Committee to deliberate on whether the above rules, or some version thereof, can be incorporated in legislation. Be this as it may, the Knesset must not allow an unelected Supreme Court to violate the principles of democracy by becoming a super-legislature or by substituting its will for the will of the people.

The judicial branch of government betrays democracy when, instead of interpreting the law, it superciliously makes the law. Law making must be preceded by political deliberation, requiring the ability to reconcile diverse opinions and interests, as well as the assistance of experts in various fields of knowledge. The Court simply lacks the research facilities available to the legislature branch of government. Whereas the primary concern of the Judiciary is permanence, the primary concern of the Legislature is change.

The Court also lacks the facilities of the executive branch, which embraces all the ministries of government. Moreover, the executive branch is responsible for the defense of the country, which inevitably involves the use of highly classified information. The Supreme Court has no business substituting its judgment for that of the Executive in security matters, especially in wartime (a matter of prudence repeatedly ignored by the Barak Court).

One last word. Justice Brandeis was not only a great judge, he was also an ardent Zionist. What a contrast with the present crop of judges and anti-Zionists who now preside over the laws of Israel.

Share0
previous post
Israeli Governments Have Betrayed the People: A New Kind of Leadership is Urgently Needed
next post
The United Coalition for Jerusalem
LanoitYarco

Related Articles

Theocracy Versus Judaism: How the Jews of Israel Have Been Deceived and Disempowered (I)

LanoitYarcoJune 11, 2008August 8, 2020

Why the Knesset Tolerates Judicial Imperialism

LanoitYarcoFebruary 6, 2007August 9, 2020

מלחמת היהודים ביהודים

LanoitYarcoAugust 25, 2007August 9, 2020

Israel and USA News

The Foundation Blog strives to provide Israel and USA News, and offers a wide range of statistics and analyzed opinions of many correspondents who highlight developments and events from Jewish people and communities in Israel and the USA as well. If you would like to know more about reliable political news and if you need more information about today in Israel news, do not hesitate to contact foundation1.org

Recent Posts

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200

Categories

  • Islam & Arab (79)
  • Democratic Methods (76)
  • Judaism (72)
  • Politicians (64)
  • Beliefs & Perspectives (64)
  • Oslo/Peace Process (63)
  • Ethics (59)
  • US & Global Policy (49)
  • Currnet Issues (48)
  • Foreign Policy (35)
  • Representation (28)
  • Israel’s Sovereignty (27)

Today in Israel News

The Research Institute Oslo Peace plans research on the circumstances and all conditions in order to manage peaceful relations between states, people and groups. This is an independent institute that owns its personal editorial offices and journals. By following the Foundation Blog, you will be updated about Israel and USA news and also the latest democratic political news.

Editor's Picks

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200
logo
Get in Touch
Contact us: [email protected]
@2019 - foundation1.org. All Right Reserved.
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
1849