The Foundation for Constitutional Democracy

  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • Oslo/Peace Process
  • Yaalon’s Plan
Oslo/Peace Process Politicians

Yaalon’s Plan

by LanoitYarcoJanuary 4, 2009August 7, 20200459
Share0

A Brief Lesson in Political Logic

A question has arisen regarding my December 29 critique of the Yaalon Plan on Israel National Radio. That plan, recall, is based on General Yaalon’s policy paper “Israel and the Palestinians: A New Strategy.”

Yaalon opposes the Oslo Agreement because its architects favor withdrawal from Judea and Samaria before the Palestinians develop the economic, political, and judicial infrastructure required to make the Palestinian Authority a reliable negotiating peace partner with Israel. But this implies that Yaalon is not opposed in principle to a Palestinian state—to put it in negative terms.

It may therefore be logically assumed that anyone who understands and endorses the Yaalon plan is not opposed in principle to a Palestinian state.

In contrast, Moshe is opposed in principle to the establishment of a Palestinian state in Judea and Samaria for religious reasons.

Meanwhile, Arieh is opposed in principle to a Palestinian state for geo-strategic reasons, since he regards Judea and Samaria essential for Israel’s survival now and in the foreseeable future. Since Moshe agrees with Arieh’s assessment, I would call both “realists.”

However, Avigdor, while discussing Yaalon’s plan, asserts that neither Moshe nor Arieh is a “realist.” Given this assertion, it would be reasonable to conclude that Avigdor is not opposed in principle to a Palestinian state.

If Avigdor denies this, either he is not being logical, or he has other reasons or motives for not opposing a Palestinian state. Two are indicated in my above-mentioned report of December 29.

Share0
previous post
Only Dead Fish Go With the Stream
next post
Destroy the Enemy to Obtain One Hundred Years of Peace
LanoitYarco

Related Articles

A Message from Prof. Paul Eidelberg

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2005August 10, 2020

Why Sharon Had Ya’alon Ditched

LanoitYarcoMarch 24, 2005August 10, 2020

An Interview with Benjamin Netanyahu

LanoitYarcoJanuary 19, 2007August 12, 2020

Israel and USA News

The Foundation Blog strives to provide Israel and USA News, and offers a wide range of statistics and analyzed opinions of many correspondents who highlight developments and events from Jewish people and communities in Israel and the USA as well. If you would like to know more about reliable political news and if you need more information about today in Israel news, do not hesitate to contact foundation1.org

Recent Posts

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200

Categories

  • Islam & Arab (79)
  • Democratic Methods (76)
  • Judaism (72)
  • Politicians (64)
  • Beliefs & Perspectives (64)
  • Oslo/Peace Process (63)
  • Ethics (59)
  • US & Global Policy (49)
  • Currnet Issues (48)
  • Foreign Policy (35)
  • Representation (28)
  • Israel’s Sovereignty (27)

Today in Israel News

The Research Institute Oslo Peace plans research on the circumstances and all conditions in order to manage peaceful relations between states, people and groups. This is an independent institute that owns its personal editorial offices and journals. By following the Foundation Blog, you will be updated about Israel and USA news and also the latest democratic political news.

Editor's Picks

To Win: Call the Enemy by His Right Name

LanoitYarcoAugust 11, 2020August 11, 2020
August 11, 2020August 11, 20200

Israel Devoid Of Any Ideology: What Is To Be Done?

LanoitYarcoAugust 10, 2020August 10, 2020
August 10, 2020August 10, 20200
logo
Get in Touch
Contact us: [email protected]
@2019 - foundation1.org. All Right Reserved.
Foundation Blog
  • Home
  • About FCD
  • Engage!
  • Store
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
1213